Rebecca Hersman: Destroying Chemicals Isn't the Same as Ending Chemical Warfare
The disarmament worked. The deterrence didn't.
After the sarin attack on East Ghouta in August 2013, Syria joined the Chemical Weapons Convention. International inspectors entered an active war zone, and more than 1,200 tonnes of declared chemicals and precursors were removed from more than twenty sites and destroyed. It was dangerous, technical and unprecedented, and it deserves to be called an achievement.
Then the attacks continued, with chlorine.
The person who helped build the solution
Rebecca Hersman wasn't a commentator watching from outside. From 2009 to 2015 she was the Pentagon's Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense for Countering Weapons of Mass Destruction, working on proliferation prevention, arms control and WMD response, including Syria's chemical disarmament. She later directed the Defense Threat Reduction Agency until January 2025, running programs across more than fifty countries.
Her 2016 essay in War on the Rocks made a simple and uncomfortable argument: destroying chemicals is not the same as destroying the willingness to use them.
Why chlorine changed the bargain
Sarin is a purpose-built nerve agent with no other use. Chlorine is used lawfully worldwide for water treatment, sanitation and industry. The Convention prohibits using any toxic chemical as a weapon, but chlorine's ubiquity created an opening. A government could hand over declared nerve agent material while retaining access to chlorine through ordinary industrial channels, and a pressurized cylinder dropped from a helicopter needs no advanced warhead.
Hersman's strategic point was about what others would learn from watching. If chlorine attacks produced fear and tactical advantage while drawing only limited consequences, the lesson wouldn't be that chemical weapons had been defeated. It would be that some chemical use sits below the threshold that triggers real punishment. Once that's believed, the prohibition starts to behave less like a hard boundary and more like a calculated risk.
The hospital in the cave
In January 2026, the OPCW concluded there were reasonable grounds to believe the Syrian Arab Air Force carried out a chlorine attack near Kafr Zeita on 1 October 2016. A pressurized cylinder struck near ventilation openings serving a cave system that housed the Al Maghara hospital. The cylinder ruptured and chlorine spread through the valley, injuring 35 named people and affecting dozens more.
The target wasn't a military formation. It was a place where wounded and frightened people had gone underground to escape conventional bombing. That's the detail worth sitting with, because it inverts an ordinary assumption about safety: the enclosed space that protects you from fragments can hold contaminated air, and the ventilation that makes it usable is the way gas gets in.
The conflict in your own plan
This creates a practical tension most families never think about. Chlorine is heavier than air and collects in low and poorly ventilated places. Sarin vapor also settles. So the safest place during a missile or bombing attack, a basement or an underground shelter, may be the worst place during a toxic gas release.
There's no universal answer. It depends on the agent, where the release is, the wind and official instructions. What a household can do is think about it in advance: know a low shelter for blast and a higher inside room for gas, know how to shut off the ventilation, and have masks where you'd use them. Our guides on evacuating or sheltering in place and setting up a safe room cover both sides.
A mask can't make that decision for you. It gives you protected breathing and vision while you carry it out.
Ten years later, the undeclared material
In May 2026, the OPCW announced that its experts, working with Syria's new authorities, had found a significant quantity of chemical weapons and related material that had never been declared: dozens of undeclared munitions, aerial bombs of the type used in the 2017 attacks at Ltamenah and Khan Shaykhun, rockets of the type used at Ghouta in 2013, separately stored chemicals, equipment and thousands of pages of documents. The Director-General said it confirmed the organization's repeated assessment that the former government had withheld information and tried to mislead inspectors about the scale of its program.
That announcement came a decade after Hersman warned that removing declared chemicals wasn't the same as ending a program. Our articles on Syria's hidden chemical weapons and Tamir Hayman's warning about retained expertise follow that thread.
What a household takes from it
Chlorine is the most likely chemical hazard for most families anywhere, war or no war, because it's everywhere in industry. A full-face mask with a CBRN or B-rated filter protects breathing and eyes while you get indoors or get away: the Israeli 4A1 for clean-shaven adults, the Sapphire hood for beards and glasses, and powered hoods or youth masks for children. See gas masks for chlorine and ammonia for which filters do what.
Frequently asked questions
Did Syria give up its chemical weapons?
It gave up what it declared: over 1,200 tonnes, removed and destroyed. In 2026 the OPCW found substantial undeclared munitions and material.
Why is chlorine used as a weapon?
Because it's legally and widely available for industrial use, and a crude cylinder is enough to release it.
Should I shelter low or high in a gas release?
Higher, for heavy gases like chlorine. Lower, for blast. Follow official instructions about which threat you're facing.
About this article: it draws on "Syria's Toxic War" by Rebecca Hersman, War on the Rocks, 2016, the OPCW's January 2026 attribution report on Kafr Zeita, the OPCW's May 2026 announcement on undeclared Syrian chemical weapons, and CDC guidance on chlorine. Rebecca Hersman, the Defense Threat Reduction Agency, War on the Rocks, the OPCW and the CDC are not affiliated with CBRNMASKS.COM and have not endorsed it or its products. Analysis and recommendations are by David Magen, founder of CBRNMASKS.COM. Former combat research officer in the IDF Training and Doctrine Branch and former reserve officer in Israel's National Emergency Authority.
Primary Sources
- Rebecca Hersman — "Syria's Toxic War: Chemical Weapons Are Undermining Deterrence and Nonproliferation," War on the Rocks, 2016
- OPCW — Kafr Zeita chlorine attack attribution report, January 2026
- OPCW — Discovery of undeclared Syrian chemical weapons, May 27, 2026
- CDC — Chlorine emergency information
Analysis and preparedness conclusions by David Magen, founder of CBRNMASKS.COM; former combat research officer in the IDF Training and Doctrine Branch; former reserve officer in Israel's National Emergency Authority. Rebecca Hersman, the Defense Threat Reduction Agency, War on the Rocks, and the OPCW are not affiliated with CBRNMASKS.COM and have not endorsed the company or its products.