Brooke Buddemeier on Fallout: Why the Building You Choose Matters Most
Brooke Buddemeier is a health physicist at Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory in California, and has spent more than thirty years working on what happens after a nuclear detonation. He led the technical team behind the U.S. government's 2022 planning guidance for responding to one, and in 2024 he joined the National Academies' Nuclear and Radiation Studies Board.
His central message is simple and runs against instinct. Outside the zone of destruction, the thing that saves most lives isn't evacuation, medicine or equipment. It's going into the right building and staying there. In the laboratory's training material, fallout is described as the greatest preventable injury after a nuclear detonation.
Most people in a city would survive the blast
People tend to imagine a nuclear attack as all-or-nothing. In reality, buildings block heat and radiation unevenly, and well beyond the zone of severe damage, large numbers of people survive the first effects. What threatens them next is fallout: soil and debris pulled up into the cloud, made radioactive and falling back as dust over the following minutes and hours. That's the danger they can still do something about.
Not all buildings are equal
Buddemeier's research measures shelters by their protection factor: how much they reduce radiation compared with standing outside. The differences are big.
| Where you are | Rough level of protection |
|---|---|
| In a car | Almost none |
| Ground floor of a wooden house | Low: cuts exposure by perhaps half |
| Basement of a house | Moderate: often around ten times less |
| Middle floors or core of a large concrete or brick building | High: often ten times or much more |
| Deep basement or underground car park of a large building | Very high |
The pattern is about mass and distance. The more concrete, brick or earth between you and the dust settling on roofs and streets outside, the better. Stay away from outside walls and the roof, and away from windows.
The car is the wrong choice
The instinct after an explosion is to get in the car and drive away. Buddemeier and U.S. official guidance both say don't. A car gives almost no protection from fallout, roads will be blocked by debris, crashes and everyone else with the same idea, and you'd spend the most dangerous hours outdoors. The best available building now beats a better one you'd reach too late.
The hardest instruction: don't go to your child
For parents, this is the advice that's hardest to follow. If your children are at school, the school will shelter them. Driving across town to collect them puts you outside during the worst period, and you may bring fallout dust in with you. A child in the middle of a large school building may already be safer than in your car.
The answer is to agree on it as a family in advance: if this ever happens, everyone shelters where they are and reunites when authorities say it's safe. It's much easier to follow a plan you made calmly than to make that decision in the moment.
Moving to a better shelter
Buddemeier's modeling also looked at people who end up somewhere poor, like a wooden house or a glass-fronted shop. If a much better shelter is a short walk away, moving after the first intense period can lower the total dose, as long as the move is quick. It's a judgment call, and official instructions come first. If you do move, cover your skin, wear a mask so you don't breathe the dust, and take off your outer clothing when you arrive.
How long to stay
Fallout radiation fades quickly in the first hours and days. Official guidance is to stay sheltered for at least 24 hours unless authorities say otherwise, and to leave only when told. Our hour-by-hour timeline explains how fast the levels drop, and how to clean up anyone who came in from outside.
Where a mask fits
Buddemeier's work is about shelter, not equipment, and that's the right order. A gas mask doesn't block radiation. What it does is stop you breathing in radioactive dust when you have to move: getting to a better shelter, helping someone in from outside, handling contaminated clothes, or evacuating later. For that, the filter needs a high-efficiency particle layer. The Shalon M80 filter in our 4A1 gas mask kit uses glass-fiber HEPA media. For beards and glasses, the Sapphire hood does the same job without a face seal. More on this in fallout protection for families.
Frequently asked questions
What's the best place to shelter from fallout?
A basement, or the middle of a large concrete or brick building, away from outside walls and the roof.
Should I drive away after a nuclear explosion?
No. A car gives almost no protection, and roads will be jammed. Get into the nearest solid building.
Should I pick up my children from school?
No, unless authorities tell you to. Schools shelter children in place. Agree on this as a family beforehand.
Does a gas mask protect against radiation?
No. It stops you breathing in radioactive dust. Shelter is what protects you from the radiation.
About this article: it draws on public guidance by Brooke Buddemeier of Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, including the FEMA PrepTalk "Saving Lives After a Nuclear Detonation," and on FEMA and CDC radiation emergency guidance. Brooke Buddemeier, Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, FEMA and the CDC are not affiliated with CBRNMASKS.COM and have not endorsed it or its products. Analysis and recommendations are by David Magen, founder of CBRNMASKS.COM. Former combat research officer in the IDF Training and Doctrine Branch and former reserve officer in Israel's National Emergency Authority.
Primary Sources
- Brooke Buddemeier — FEMA PrepTalk Discussion Guide: Saving Lives After a Nuclear Detonation
- Brooke Buddemeier — "Reducing the Consequences of a Nuclear Detonation: Recent Research," The Bridge, Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory
- FEMA — Planning Guidance for Response to a Nuclear Detonation, 2022
- CDC — Radiation Emergencies: Get Inside
- Ready.gov — Radiation Emergencies
- CDC/NIOSH — Respirators that Protect Against CBRN Hazards
Analysis and preparedness conclusions by David Magen, founder of CBRNMASKS.COM; former combat research officer in the IDF Training and Doctrine Branch; former reserve officer in Israel's National Emergency Authority. Brooke Buddemeier, Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, the National Academies, FEMA, CDC, and NIOSH are not affiliated with CBRNMASKS.COM and have not endorsed the company or its products.