Why Gas Masks Still Decide Battles: A Former NATO CBRN Commander on Ukraine

Discussion of the war in Ukraine is dominated by missiles, drones, artillery and electronic warfare. Colonel Hamish de Bretton-Gordon argues that one of the simplest pieces of protective equipment may decide whether soldiers can hold a position at all.

De Bretton-Gordon commanded the UK's Joint CBRN Regiment and NATO's rapid-reaction CBRN battalion, served more than two decades in the British Army with deployments including the Gulf War, Bosnia, Kosovo, Iraq and Afghanistan, and later advised humanitarian and medical organizations working in areas hit by chemical attacks. Writing for Forces News in July 2024, he argued that supplying Ukraine with effective gas masks would deliver a large tactical return for a tiny fraction of the cost of offensive weapons.

Chemical weapons don't need to kill to work

This is the insight that makes his argument worth reading even for civilians. Battlefield chemical use today is tactical rather than mass-casualty. An attacking force doesn't need to kill everyone in a trench. It needs the trench to become impossible to occupy. An irritant or choking agent does that, and once soldiers are out in the open they're exposed to artillery, drones and small arms.

So a gas mask isn't only protective equipment. It preserves combat power. A unit that can stay in cover is far harder to dislodge than one that has to run every time a canister lands.

What inspectors have confirmed since

Three OPCW Technical Assistance Visit reports have confirmed toxic chemicals in samples from Ukrainian positions:

  • November 2024: two designated laboratories, working independently, confirmed the riot control agent CS in grenade and soil samples from a trench near Illinka in the Dnipropetrovsk region.
  • February 2025: CS confirmed in samples from three further alleged incidents along the confrontation lines in the same region.
  • June 2025: CS confirmed again in another incident, with samples collected alongside remnants of an FPV drone. Director-General Arias called the repeated discovery of riot control agent grenades near active conflict zones deeply concerning.

Separately, the US government determined in May 2024 that Russian forces had used chloropicrin against Ukrainian troops as a method of warfare. Using riot control agents as a method of warfare is prohibited under the Chemical Weapons Convention.

Why CS in a trench is different from CS in a street

CS is ordinary tear gas, and in policing it's meant to produce temporary effects that people escape by moving to fresh air. In a trench that option doesn't exist. Leaving means exposure to direct fire. The same chemical, in a situation where the victim can't leave, becomes something else, which is exactly why the Convention treats its use in warfare differently. Chloropicrin is more serious again: a First World War choking agent that injures the lungs and eyes.

Neither needs to kill many people to make a defensible position uninhabitable for long enough to matter.

Old equipment is worse than no equipment

De Bretton-Gordon warned that some Ukrainian personnel were relying on old Soviet masks, or had nothing. A mask can look complete while the rubber has hardened or cracked, the valves are damaged, the straps have perished, the sealing surface has warped, the visor is damaged, the filter threads have corroded, or the filter inside is opened, degraded or simply wrong.

The worst outcome isn't having no mask. It's believing an unserviceable one protects you. That applies to anyone who bought surplus equipment years ago and has never examined it. See our guide to whether surplus gas masks are safe.

The filter and the fit

The filter decides what the system actually reduces. A 40mm thread means a filter will attach. It says nothing about which substances it handles. Check the model before you trust it, the manufacturer's stated protection range, whether it's still factory sealed, its date and storage history, and whether it suits what you expect to face. Our filter guide goes through this.

Fit decides whether any of it matters. If the mask doesn't seal, contaminated air comes in around the face instead of through the filter. Wrong size, loose or damaged straps, stubble, glasses arms crossing the seal, facial shape or scarring all cause leaks, and a model that fits one person may not fit another. Don't wait for an emergency to open the box and try it on. Our fit and seal guide explains the checks.

What a filter mask can't do

It cleans the air around you. It makes no oxygen, so it's not for oxygen-deficient atmospheres or for entering somewhere whose contents and concentration are unknown. It doesn't protect against blast, fragments, fire, heat, chemicals absorbed through skin, or penetrating radiation. It's one defensive layer, alongside shelter, protective clothing, decontamination, medical treatment and official instructions.

Why this reaches beyond Ukraine

Cheap drones and commercial components are spreading fast, and the ability to deliver smoke, irritants or industrial chemicals is no longer limited to major military powers. Our article on drones and chemical weapons looks at what the OPCW has documented.

A civilian's priorities are different from a soldier's: move away from the hazard when told to, get into shelter, reduce exposure, follow the authorities. But the equipment principles carry over. During an airborne chemical incident a serviceable full-face mask with the right filter adds a layer while you shelter or evacuate, and it has to be reachable. A mask at the back of a loft is no use in a short-warning event.

For a household: the Israeli 4A1 for clean-shaven adults, the Sapphire hood for beards and glasses, the Quartz hood for young children and the Multipro for babies, with sealed spare filters. For tear gas specifically, the riot control kit is a lower-cost entry point.

Frequently asked questions

Have chemical weapons been used in Ukraine?

OPCW laboratories have confirmed CS, a riot control agent, in samples from several incidents. The US government determined in 2024 that chloropicrin had also been used. Using riot control agents in warfare is prohibited.

Why does tear gas matter militarily?

Because a soldier in a trench can't leave to get fresh air without being exposed to fire. It makes a position uninhabitable.

Is an old surplus mask good enough?

Only if you've checked it. Hardened rubber, bad valves, a warped seal or an unsuitable filter are common and dangerous.

About this article: it draws on "Gas Masks Can Protect Ukraine's Armed Forces" by Colonel Hamish de Bretton-Gordon OBE, Forces News, July 2024, on the OPCW Technical Assistance Visit reports on Ukraine, document S/2338/2024 of November 2024, the second report of February 2025 and document S/2415/2025 of June 2025, and on US government statements. Colonel de Bretton-Gordon, NATO, the UK Ministry of Defence, Forces News and the OPCW are not affiliated with CBRNMASKS.COM and have not endorsed it or its products. Analysis and recommendations are by David Magen, founder of CBRNMASKS.COM. Former combat research officer in the IDF Training and Doctrine Branch and former reserve officer in Israel's National Emergency Authority.

Primary Sources

  • Colonel Hamish de Bretton-Gordon OBE — "Gas Masks Can Protect Ukraine's Armed Forces — and the UK Must Lead the Way," Forces News, July 16, 2024
  • OPCW — First Technical Assistance Visit Report (CS confirmed, November 2024)
  • OPCW — Second Technical Assistance Visit Report (CS confirmed, February 2025)
  • OPCW — Third Technical Assistance Visit Report (CS confirmed, June 2025)

Analysis and preparedness conclusions by David Magen, founder of CBRNMASKS.COM; former combat research officer in the IDF Training and Doctrine Branch; former reserve officer in Israel's National Emergency Authority. Colonel Hamish de Bretton-Gordon, NATO, the United Kingdom Ministry of Defense, Forces News, and the OPCW are not affiliated with CBRNMASKS.COM and have not endorsed any product sold by it.

Back to blog