Why Experts Say the Old Definition of WMD No Longer Fits

The term "weapon of mass destruction" comes from 1948, when the United Nations defined it around atomic explosives, radioactive weapons and lethal chemical and biological agents. The picture behind the words is a state program: a factory, a stockpile, a missile. A group of American defense analysts has argued that the picture is now too narrow, and that it shapes how governments look for threats.

The argument

Al Mauroni, who has worked on US military chemical and biological defense policy for around four decades and directed the US Air Force Center for Strategic Deterrence Studies; Zachary Kallenborn, who researches drone warfare and catastrophic risk at King's College London; Dr. W. Seth Carus, emeritus professor at the National Defense University's center for WMD studies and a former White House adviser on biodefense; and retired Colonel Ron Fizer set out the case in War on the Rocks, republished by the National Defense University.

Their point isn't that every new technology should be called a weapon of mass destruction. It's that arms control was built around physical bottlenecks, and some of those bottlenecks have weakened. Knowledge moves as data. Equipment that was once specialized is now commercial. A single chemical assassination can have political effects out of all proportion to its casualties. The operative word, they suggest, may no longer be "mass" but "effect."

Drones changed what defenders watch for

Chemical and biological weapons have always had a delivery problem. Wind, temperature and the fragility of the material make results unpredictable, and the traditional ways of delivering them, aircraft and artillery, are visible and attributable. Small uncrewed aircraft changed the calculation enough that the international chemical weapons watchdog took formal notice.

In June 2025, the OPCW reported on samples collected after an alleged toxic chemical incident near a Ukrainian position. Two independent designated laboratories found the riot-control agent CS in grenade samples and in nearby environmental material, and a wipe from the burned frame of a recovered FPV drone contained CS at a very low level. The report didn't assign responsibility. By 2026 the OPCW was formally monitoring developments in uncrewed aerial systems for their implications under the Chemical Weapons Convention. Our article on drones and chemical weapons in Ukraine goes into that record.

The institutional problem

The analysts' deeper concern is convergence: capabilities that are individually unremarkable, and individually legal, drawing attention only when combined. Export controls written around a specific chemical precursor, a specific organism or a specific machine have limited reach against that pattern. The US Department of Defense's 2023 strategy for countering weapons of mass destruction describes a similar trend toward more accessible technology, and doesn't claim the problem is solved.

What this means for a household

This is a problem for governments, intelligence services and arms-control bodies. Nothing in it is a household's to fix. What it does mean for families is a modest, practical conclusion: the range of plausible airborne hazards is a little wider than it was, and warning times in some scenarios may be short. Equipment bought after an incident begins arrives too late.

The sensible preparation is the same for any such hazard, and it isn't elaborate:

  • A shelter room you've thought about in advance. See setting up a safe room.
  • A mask or hood that fits each person, stored there: the Israeli 4A1 for clean-shaven adults, the Sapphire hood for beards and glasses, the 10A1 for children 8 to 14, and powered hoods for younger children.
  • Sealed spare filters, water, medication and a radio.
  • One practice run, so nobody is learning the straps for the first time during an alert.

Our family CBRN kit guide has the full list.

Frequently asked questions

Are drones now considered weapons of mass destruction?

No. The argument is that the old category doesn't capture how catastrophic effects might be produced, not that drones belong inside it.

Has a chemical agent been delivered by drone?

The OPCW has documented CS, a riot-control agent, in samples from a Ukrainian incident including a trace on a recovered FPV drone frame. It did not assign responsibility, and that is not the same as a mass-casualty agent.

Does any of this change what a family needs?

No. A shelter plan, a mask that fits each person and sealed filters cover these hazards as they cover older ones.

About this article: it draws on "A Weapons of Mass Destruction Strategy for the 21st Century" by Al Mauroni, Zachary Kallenborn, W. Seth Carus and Ron Fizer, published by War on the Rocks and republished by the National Defense University, and on OPCW reporting on Ukraine. The authors, War on the Rocks, the National Defense University, the US Department of Defense and the OPCW are not affiliated with CBRNMASKS.COM and have not endorsed it or its products. Analysis and recommendations are by David Magen, founder of CBRNMASKS.COM. Former combat research officer in the IDF Training and Doctrine Branch and former reserve officer in Israel's National Emergency Authority.

Primary Sources

  • Al Mauroni, Zachary Kallenborn, W. Seth Carus, Ron Fizer — "A Weapons of Mass Destruction Strategy for the 21st Century," War on the Rocks / National Defense University
  • DoD — 2023 Strategy for Countering Weapons of Mass Destruction
  • OPCW — Third Technical Assistance Visit Report, Ukraine, June 2025
  • CDC/NIOSH — Respirators that Protect Against CBRN Hazards

Analysis and preparedness conclusions by David Magen, founder of CBRNMASKS.COM; former combat research officer in the IDF Training and Doctrine Branch; former reserve officer in Israel's National Emergency Authority. Al Mauroni, Zachary Kallenborn, W. Seth Carus, Ron Fizer, War on the Rocks, the National Defense University, the U.S. Department of Defense, and the OPCW are not affiliated with CBRNMASKS.COM and have not endorsed the company or its products.

Back to blog